I can't believe that I missed this thread, b/c all of this is right up my alley!!!
I'm currently in the process of becoming an ordained minister in the United Methodist Church... I'm working on my masters at a Divinity School for that very reason! so all of what you guys have to say is so interesting, and i'm glad that we are having this conversation.
I have to be honest that although I am a Christian, heck, especially since i'm a christian who wants to be a minister, I still have doubts, and I still struggle with what exactly God wants from us and how to respond. While I know that God is behind all of our religious traditions, and rituals, and scripture, I also believe that God is bigger than who we say God is. So I try to be as faithful as possible to my own tradition - asking questions if necessary, challenging where appropriate - but at the same time, I also see God's work in the world in other places. I have atheist friends who have shown God to me more than some of my Christian friends... I know Buddhists who demonstrate more faithful living according to the will of God than I do myself (and most buddhists dont' believe there is a God!)... I'm currently in a class that is exploring how Judaism and Christianity split from one another - and it is interesting that as long as four centuries after Jesus died, in some communities, there was no distinction!
There was some discussion about the Trinity above, and that whole concept is just so strange and wonderful that it is hard to wrap your head around. I used to think of the Trinity as water... and that you can find it in three modes: ice, liquid, air... but I don't think that is exactly right either... I think it is supposed to be hard to understand - it is supposed to be a mystery... and our little human minds just aren't big enough to fully understand what exactly God is and how God (with Jesus and the Holy Spirit) acts in the world... I tend to just talk about God, and mean all three "parts" because I think that our society has really tried to separate God and Jesus and the Holy Spirit... we think of them as three different things, but I don't think they are... but they also aren't identical... oh geez, this is so confusing! words just aren't a good way of talking about something that is indescribable!!!
anywho... I need to go prepare a sunday school lesson now... oh! but if any of you are interested in the crazy ramblings of a divinity school student, check out my blog... i think it is listed when you click on my name and look at my profile.