1)Eat For Your Goal-
2) Eat for Balance
3) Eat the right foods
4) Eat Often
5) Eat 1 ingredient items
6) Drink Water
That's it. If you stick to that you will get results, plain and simple.
I'm going to take issue with most of this, and I'm fairly surprised more people don't. Let's start with the idea that nutrition is easy to understand and nutritional guidelines are easy to follow. Trying to break down every food you eat into percentages of fats and proteins and carbs, take note of whether the protein is lean or the fat is saturated, and then calculate how many calories you're eating and how many calories you
should be eating... doesn't sound very easy to me.
Number 1 - Eat for Your Goal - First of all, BMI only gives a glance of where you might be on the overall healthy scale, but it does not suggest the amount of calories you'd need to maintain your weight. A 250lb muscle builder needs much more than a 250lb fatty. On top of that, counting calories is arduous and frustrating, not to mention very imprecise.
Number 2 - Eat for Balance - The China Study, one of the most comprehensive studies ever done on the topic of nutrition suggests that animal protein can literally turn cancer on and off in our bodies. Inuits, on the other hand, generally ate
only animals as plants were very sparse. 30/30/30 seems very arbitrary to me in the face of this.
Number 3 - Eat the Right Foods - Although I can't take issue with eating a lot of fruits and veggies, you neglect the benefits of red meat and egg yolks when discussing protein.
Number 4 - Eat Often - It's been suggested that a big reason the French stay thin is because they only eat 3 times a day. Eating whenever you want instead of holding out until mealtime could be the reason you're fat.
Number 5 - Eat 1 Ingredient Items - If 85% of my meals were from 1 ingredient items, I'd kill myself. Chefs are constantly creating new flavor combinations that entice us and make our mouths water. I, for one, won't be denying them.
Number 6 - Drink water - Guess I can't deny this... water sustains us and most people probably don't get enough.
To me this all equals one thing - Don't trust the wisdom of the nutrition scientists or the food industry. The scientists don't know enough yet (evidenced by their constantly changing suggestions) and the food industry just wants to make more money. Instead I trust the collective wisdom of cultures other than my own (we're all fat);
eat fresh food that tastes good, not too much, not too often, and enjoy it. To me, that's much easier to follow