Pro-Obesity Movement

I think we need fewer people trying to dictate other people's lives and more people who are willing to take care of themselves regardless of what the media says.

Totally agree with you on that!

Just to let the people know that think there is no pro-fat thing going on, I was flipping channels the other day and Oprah had that blond guy from ***** Eye on her show and he took photos of a very overweight woman and put a huge banner of one on a tall building. He asked passerbyers what they would rate her as on a scale 1-10 and they said 7-10. When she saw it she asked him how much he paid them. He had to pay them! How can someone look at a person they don't know anything about that is more than 70lbs overweight and say she's a knockout 10? I understand the whole point of the show is to make fat people more confident, which it is great to boost someone's self confidence, but I don't think it should be done by lying.
 
Totally agree with you on that!

Just to let the people know that think there is no pro-fat thing going on, I was flipping channels the other day and Oprah had that blond guy from ***** Eye on her show and he took photos of a very overweight woman and put a huge banner of one on a tall building. He asked passerbyers what they would rate her as on a scale 1-10 and they said 7-10. When she saw it she asked him how much he paid them. He had to pay them! How can someone look at a person they don't know anything about that is more than 70lbs overweight and say she's a knockout 10? I understand the whole point of the show is to make fat people more confident, which it is great to boost someone's self confidence, but I don't think it should be done by lying.

Yeah, I've seen that show before. I understand the idea of it, but I think they're approaching the problem incorrectly. The point is to be comfortable with yourself, not necessarily with your body, but with yourself as a person. They're taking people with low self esteem and trying to convince them that they LOOK good. That doesn't really work. There's a lot more to self esteem than how you look. Convincing someone that they look good by handpicking strangers' responses doesn't tackle the true problem. It's all just superficial.

I think it's perfectly normal to be unsatisfied with the state of your body but still love and admire yourself. In fact, I think good self esteem is essential if anyone wants to make a real and positive change to their body.
 
There are groups like Overeaters Anonymous who have been criticized for encouraging bulimic and binge eating women to accept powerlessness over food (as well as feminist talk). Some of these ideas are a little too extreme for most people.
 
Is the model pictured on the first page the one who committed suicide recently? The model who jumped from her 9th floor apartment was always smiling so it was a bit of a shock.
 
i agree with spicypumpkin, there is a constant barrage of pro-obesity rhetoric in today's society. and yes, it's disguised as pro-self esteem, but really it's about obesity bc that's where society is generally headed.

where are these messages? Dove's "real beauty" campaign for example. i'm not saying it's ALL bad...they have some very positive messages in there (i.e. don't kill yourself if you don't look like an airbrushed model in a magazine) but they promote self-acceptance and loving yourself the way you are. which is fine in theory, but when one is overweight or obese, why accept that?

someone in the thread said that we live in a blameless society...which is exactly true. no one wants to take responsibility for being fat, it's always because work is stressful, partners eat badly and there's no time for exercise. (this is NOT directed at people who have physical disorders/medication that cause them to gain weight) it's so easy to blame society, lifestyle and others that no one wants to accept that with a little sacrifice, a healthy lifestyle IS possible.

for example, i am a full time student who works part time. i live a 2hr commute from my school (or 1 hr drive each way, if i choose to drive). as you can imagine, my time is limited. despite this, during my first year of my program (last year) i managed to drop 20 lbs over a 6 or 8 month period by MAKING time to work out and eating healthy food. when in class/between classes, i sit with friends who eat pizza/fries/wings and drink cokes and redbull. and yes, i pull out my wholewheat bread veggie sandwich or pasta or brown rice and beans/salad that i made last night or on the weekend. it's tough but it's do-able.

people eat fast food and even pre-packaged grocery store items without reading or understanding what the label says. and when they gain weight, tend to say "i didn't know that was so bad for me!" well, if you bothered educating yourself in the first place, you wouldn't have gained the weight. this IS 2008, and we have Google.

other ways pro-obesity is encouraged? many...it's just covert. for example, car seats are bigger here than they are in Asia. why? because North americans are fatter. i saw a piece on the news that talked about car manufacturers coming up with "seatbelt extensions": because a significant enough percentage of Americans are having trouble fitting into seatbelts as they are.

supersize options at fastfood restaurants: yes, they are trying to make money...but they are doing so by feeding the demand of the population. same deal with fat/sugar-packed grocery store foods, especially kid foods like drink boxes and cereals. we're digging our own graves here.

the amount of fast food options versus health food options in the first place.

i used to work with troubled kids and was told to NEVER speak of calories, diets or workouts to them. if they mentioned these things, they were to be discouraged, and quietly encouraged to "just eat healthy". at 14, not a lot of kids know what healthy IS...and if adults dont guide them properly, this will just spiral into obesity or conversely, eating disorders.

political correctness in general about labeling fat, even through television and media. unless someone is making fun of someone else, a fat person is simply "large" or "big-boned".

society today seems to be teaching people to accept mediocrity. if you're not your best, who cares? just accept it. you don't have to change a thing. if YOU accept you, that's all that matters.

my POV? if YOU are lazy, uneducated and unmotivated in the first place...why should anyone else in society accept you? i don't want to. and i don't want to have kids in the kind of society that accepts you either. giving anything less than 100% in any part of life is selling yourself short.
 
The pro-body image movement is like any movement: you get people who stand for what is right and you get idiots who take it and run. At the root is basically a statement that you shouldn't be unhappy with the way you look. I think that's great because most Americans are unhappy with their appearance. On the other hand, you get fat people who are too lazy and unfocused to lose weight who use this as a cop-out to continue their lifestyle.
 
Back
Top