how often should i weight myself?

[Focus], you're conducting a critical thinking seminar with someone who has absolutely no interest in what you're teaching. Personally, I'm amused at the futility of your attempts, but I hope txsqlchick doesn't mistakenly take that as laughing at her expense. Quite frankly, I think she's winning the trade here because you're showing yourself incapable (more than likely unwilling) of adjusting your message to your audience.
 
I weigh myself after every BM and urination, feel free to use me as an example in a case study.
 
JDhd said:
[Focus], you're conducting a critical thinking seminar with someone who has absolutely no interest in what you're teaching. Personally, I'm amused at the futility of your attempts, but I hope txsqlchick doesn't mistakenly take that as laughing at her expense. Quite frankly, I think she's winning the trade here because you're showing yourself incapable (more than likely unwilling) of adjusting your message to your audience.
Click to expand...

Quite frankly, I think you have really bad reading comprehension, or some motive for being intellectually dishonest. I'll let you decide which!

No, no, I should really assume it's option 1. Allow me to explain where you erred:

Premise 1: How a person feels about the truth is at all relevant to the inevitability of its transmission.
Premise 2: "Seeming" and "being" have the same meaning.
Premise 3: "Incapable" and "unwilling" have the same meaning.
Premise 4: The burden of successful transmission is on the communicant.
Premise 5: "Audient" and "audience" have the same meaning.
Premise 6: You are even ballpark of being capable of condescending to me.

I hope this helps. Sadly, you probably think I am 'losing this trade', too. Maybe one day you'll be smarter and know more and not embarrass yourself unnecessarily. =)
 
You're getting bent about nothing, I was just teasing you and you blew it way out of proportion. Like I was alluding to, and it's my fault for not making it clear, you're obviously right, but she's not interested in hearing it. So, I'm sitting here laughing because it's like you're arguing with a brick wall. Although the brick wall will never win, it's also incapable of losing.

PS: Incapable and unwilling do not have the same meaning. Incapable means you don't have the ability, unwilling means you have the ability but choose not to use it.
 
JDhd said:
You're getting bent about nothing, I was just teasing you and you blew it way out of proportion. Like I was alluding to, and it's my fault for not making it clear, you're obviously right, but she's not interested in hearing it. So, I'm sitting here laughing because it's like you're arguing with a brick wall. Although the brick wall will never win, it's also incapable of losing.

PS: Incapable and unwilling do not have the same meaning. Incapable means you don't have the ability, unwilling means you have the ability but choose not to use it.
Click to expand...


I think you're both nuts arguing about something that has no relevance whatsoever.

Both of you need this. :chillpill:
 
txsqlchick said:
I think you're both nuts arguing about something that has no relevance whatsoever.

Both of you need this. :chillpill:
Click to expand...
Regardless, you're still exhibiting a compulsive behaviour by weighing yourself everyday. Which, by definition, as focus said, is crazy. That's fine if you don't want to admit that its crazy, but that doesn't change the fact that it is. And if that works for you, great, more power to you.
 
JDhd said:
You're getting bent about nothing, I was just teasing you and you blew it way out of proportion. Like I was alluding to, and it's my fault for not making it clear, you're obviously right, but she's not interested in hearing it. So, I'm sitting here laughing because it's like you're arguing with a brick wall. Although the brick wall will never win, it's also incapable of losing.

PS: Incapable and unwilling do not have the same meaning. Incapable means you don't have the ability, unwilling means you have the ability but choose not to use it.
Click to expand...

Dude I win lots of arguments with brick walls. My sledgehammer is hyoooogeeee. :coolgleamA:

Anyway, as should be obvious to most, I only clown for my own amusement. And the possible edification of others. How people choose to interpret what I say and do is of very little consequence. What they might opine on the subject even less so. Which is my way of saying I'm not at all upset. Imo we are throwing salami at each other in the cafeteria to help pass the time until Ms. Purdy's sex ed class. :D

Damn that Ms. Purdy is fine. I wish I was old enough to give her some private lessons, yknow. Sadly, my junk doesn't work yet. :(
 
Last edited:
txsqlchick said:
That's your opinion.
Click to expand...
That's not my opinion. You're the one that stressed you need to weigh yourself everyday. It's irrational to weigh yourself everyday for all the reasons outlined in the thread The Scale Mentality. Having a need to do something irrational, regardless of anyone's opinion, is compulsive.
 
[Focus];497266 said:
Dude I win lots of arguments with brick walls. My sledgehammer is hyoooogeeee. :coolgleamA:

Anyway, as should be obvious to most, I only clown for my own amusement. And the possible edification of others. How people choose to interpret what I say and do is of very little consequence. What they might opine on the subject even less so. Which is my way of saying I'm not at all upset. Imo we are throwing salami at each other in the cafeteria to help pass the time until Ms. Purdy's sex ed class. :D

Damn that Ms. Purdy is fine. I wish I was old enough to give her some private lessons, yknow. Sadly, my junk doesn't work yet. :(
Click to expand...
Is the Ms. Purdy's sex ed class a cover-up for the fact that you're suggesting we're throwing our salami at each other? lol
 
JDhd said:
That's not my opinion. You're the one that stressed you need to weigh yourself everyday. It's irrational to weigh yourself everyday for all the reasons outlined in the thread The Scale Mentality. Having a need to do something irrational, regardless of anyone's opinion, is compulsive.
Click to expand...

You're assuming that my "need" to weigh every day is a compulsion. If you'd read what I posted here about it, it's more of a process of getting to know my body and its fluctuations.

Get off my case.
 
txsqlchick said:
You're assuming that my "need" to weigh every day is a compulsion. If you'd read what I posted here about it, it's more of a process of getting to know my body and its fluctuations...
Click to expand...

Are you charting the fluctuations? What do you do when there is a major fluctuation in your weight? Are you measuring fluctuations in BP, Ketones in Urine, BMI, Blood glucose levels, etc.?
 
Has anyone heard of the Weight Loss Registry?

They have a take on this.

It is a program started by a research group at Brown University. It is essentially a registry of people who have had weight loss success.

I had a chance to meet a member of this group and she said one of of things most strongly correlated with weight success was weighing yourself regularly (not necessarily everyday).

So there is definitely some evidence to support it, although more than 5x a week may be excessive.

Brian Dean MS,RD
Collaboration Coordinator, NutriYoga LLC
NutriYoga.com
 
I think it's a no brainer... people who become more cognizant and concerned about their weight will trend towards better weight loss and maintenance.

That said, having worked hands on with a large number of people with weight loss on an individual basis, in my experience, scale obsession tends to be quite common and really interferes with people's happiness and sanity.

It's just another metric that needs to be understood and applied properly.
 
Why are people arguing in this thread? How rude when someone asks a question that people can be so self absorbed. Continue your bickering in a pm.

Weigh yourself whenever you want. Do whatever helps. I don't even see the point in scales, don't own one and never will. But i certainly don't go putting people down who weigh themselves daily, weekly or whatever. I actually have better ways to spend my time than looking for arguments on an internet forum.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top