Martin Katahn's Rotation Diet?

Status
Not open for further replies.
December rotation - days 13 and 14

Mike - I only have juice once a week but I do like to have a daily yogurt for the probiotics and the calcium. I buy plain and sweeten with honey or molasses. I do appreciate your expertise and concern and since I obviously don't have this weight loss thing down I can't say I don't need the advice!

Did weights yesterday, indoor bike and rowing today. On to week three tomorrow.
 
Last edited:
December rotation - Day 15

I was tempted to go right to a semi-maintenance diet and continue on at 1600 but then I remembered how I have not finished a rotation properly since March. So I decided to head back down to 1000 calories a day. I reread my posts from the first three days for motivation. Right now I am actually feeling pleasantly stuffed after a huge bowl of chicken brown rice vegetable soup. I pondered having cottage cheese and lettuce for breakfast but instead went with yogurt, apple, molasses, and bran buds. Lunch was cheesy brown rice and beet greens. Snack was celery and hummus. Still have 90 calories to use later. I've also had two cups of tea and had a quarter teaspoon turmeric in each meal and snack. Feeling great, eating less and enjoying it more! Nothing to it, I can do it.
 
December Rotation - Day 15

Another enjoyable day of eating light and healthy! Yogurt, molasses, apple, and bran buds for breakfast; whole wheat spaghetti mozzarella and broccoli for lunch, pineapple for snack, salmon patty on salad and 1/2 slice whole wheat bread for supper. Anti-arthritis weights for exercise.

Weighed in at 176 this morning - that's five pounds gone in two weeks, lost and never to be found. Should be able to see 174 by the end of the rotation. Then I plan to have another 1600 calorie week before moving up to 1900.

Just one more day of 1000 calories tomorrow and all the most restrictive part of the rotation will be done. 1000 calories is very doable for me, no real problems with hunger today.
 
December Rotation - Day 16

Another enjoyable day of eating light and healthy! Yogurt, molasses, apple, and bran buds for breakfast; whole wheat spaghetti mozzarella and broccoli for lunch, pineapple for snack, salmon patty on salad and 1/2 slice whole wheat bread for supper. Anti-arthritis weights for exercise.

Weighed in at 176 this morning - that's five pounds gone in two weeks, lost and never to be found. Should be able to see 174 by the end of the rotation. Then I plan to have another 1600 calorie week before moving up to 1900.

Just one more day of 1000 calories tomorrow and all the most restrictive part of the rotation will be done. 1000 calories is very doable for me, no real problems with hunger today.
 
December rotation - day 17

Enjoyed pineapple yogurt with bran buds for breakfast, corn pasta goulash for lunch, celery and ranch dip for snack, buttercup squash, cheese, and whole wheat bread for supper.
indoor biking and rowing for exercise.

Hurray! Finished with the last of the 1000 calorie days in which I have enjoyed delicious food but in the smaller amounts that lead to a trim healthy physique. Got my favorite burgundy tweed suit hanging in view to wear soon. I'm feeling great because I am sticking to the plan. I'm beginning to read about maintenance now because that is the next challenge.
 
December Rotation - day 18

Up to 1300 calories a day today. Had the usual breakfast; whole wheat cheese sandwich, beets, squash, lettuce and cottage cheese for lunch; orange and nuts for snack; chicken, potato and carrot for supper. Not really having a problem with hunger but still feeling that I would like to be eating more. I need to mentally realize this is ENOUGH for now. Just three days to maintenance week 1!
I usually have a cup of herb tea for breakfast but several times during the rotation I've had an additional one later knowing that it's a way to feel like you are having something without adding any calories!

Adding some more exercises this week - did 10 minutes of Brill core exercises and 10 minutes on the mini trampoline "jogging" and bouncing today. So the exercise schedule is day 1 weights, day 2 bike and row, day 3 brill and tramp - then repeat on days 4,5,6 and have a 7th day of rest before it starts again! I intend to keep this up till spring.
 
Last edited:
December Rotation - Day 19

Down to 174 this morning! Back to apple molasses bran bud yogurt for breakfast - this is so satisfying for less than 300 calories and really seems to keep hunger at bay all day! Lentils and brown rice plus apple carrot salad for lunch, low fat ice cream for snack, spinach rice burgers for supper. Still having 1/2 to 1 teaspoon of turmeric per day.

Anti-arthritis weights for exercise. Reading about maintenance in the Rotation diet book. There are two chapters on learning how to resist temptations. I have been able to do that successfully with corn chips and chocolate brazil nuts (and every other food I've got around here and haven't eaten!) during this rotation. This is what I must do in the future - only allowing what Katahn calls controlled binges when you choose what and how much of a snack food or dessert you will have. I am determined to break my old bad habits and continue on with the good habits I am building during this rotation - eating less and enjoying it more.

Only two more days to go!
 
December rotation - Day 20

175 today - but that's all right. I know the scale will continue to go in the right direction if I continue to eat light and healthy and exercise.

Actually ended up at 1400 yesterday and today. Yesterday because of hunger before bed and today because of unavoidable pizza for lunch plus one small cookie and one small chocolate truffle.
The usual fruit and yogurt for breakfast, no snacks, and butter bean vegetable soup for supper.

Used the indoor bike and rowing machine today.
 
December Rotation - day 21

I am pleased with myself for not wimping out and stopping partway through as I have done so many times this year. Weighing in at 175 again this morning. Today I have been eating diuretic foods as listed in the Rotation book section on maintenance to counteract the high sodium pizza yesterday. So, cottage cheese, carrot and celery plus an orange for breakfast, ground beef in tomato sauce over potato plus broccoli for lunch, a couple tablespoons of walnuts for a snack. Then I've also had these foods not on the list - beets for a snack, corn pasta with cheese and a bit of turkey sausage, and mixed vegetables. Total calories for the day - 1250 (including a piece of whole wheat bread I had a midnight.)
 
Week 1 of Maintenance

Three days into maintenance. The bad news is that after three weeks my final weigh in is 176 - what happened to that 174? The good news is that I feel like I am 174, my suit fits, my triple chin is back down to a double, calipers show me at 25% fat which is where I want to be. I kept under 1600 for my first day of maintenance, still 176 the next morning. On second day I should have stayed at 1600 but I went up to 2200 calories! According to Katahn that could add a pound of water weight, but still 176 this morning. Today I had a light breakfast and lunch but I cooked a turkey with potato dressing and gravy, green bean casserole and cranberry applesauce for supper. So that puts me at 2200 again. That shouldn't be high enough to actually add any fat since its about maintenance level, but I am hoping to get back down to 1600 for the rest of the week.

Arthritis weights for exercise, plus shopping walking.

So final results of the December rotation - 5 pounds lighter and feeling good!
 
Aloe-

I am following your posts
As I mentioned before, I was not aware of this rotation diet idea .. but seeing the list of foods, I must confess it is not what I normally see in successful weight reducing regimens
Still seems like a relatively high ratio of carbs to protein for what is the "norm" for folks trying to shed excess pounds.

I praise the book Metabolism Miracle by Diane Kress as a great book on the subject
I share her same ideas in my own book - although go more into the exercise and other aspects than she does.

Again we are all different - so if this works for you THAT is what matters ... but if time passes and you feel stuck ---- take a second look at all those potatoes, apple sauces, corn pasta, etc....

Good luck
 
Mike - wow! you would think I was eating twinkies and potato chips from all the appalled comments you make about my food choices! You may not have heard of the rotation diet, but have you heard of the Mediterranean diet, widely agreed upon as one of the most healthful? "The Mediterranean Diet defined: Decades ago, it was the natural way of life of people from countries bordering the Mediterranean Sea, countries including; Spain, France, Italy, Greece, Portugal and North Africa. The similarity in eating habits of these countries is what is referred as the Mediterranean Diet, which consist of:
•Lots of fruits and veggies,
•Whole grain breads
•Beans, nuts, seeds
•Fish and poultry, very little meat
•Limited consumption of eggs
•and... Red Wine.
Medical studies, including the Mayo Clinic have shown that people who follow the Mediterranean Diet are less likely to have cardiovascular disease and cancer and at the same time reduced cholesterol." (from Mediterraneandieting.com)

The Rotation diet is designed to give quick weight loss without lowering metabolism which leads to rebound weight gain. "The Rotation Diet short-circuits the starvation response for several reasons. First, you use a mixed diet containing a wide variety of foods (high protein diets that cut out carbohydrates, such as bread, potatoes, fruits, and vegetables, are more likely to slow metabolic rate). Second, you don't stay on a caloric intake below 1200 (1800 for men) for more than a week. And, third, if you are a sedentary person, you get more active. (From The Rotation Diet)

I use the general principles from the Rotation diet and make up my own Mediterranean type meals although I skip the red wine and add low fat dairy products for calcium.

The dietary plan you recommended (in an earlier post to me, and to others) if followed on a daily basis would be lacking in fiber and the other abundant nutrients supplied by whole grains and fruits. That high an amount of protein is not necessary unless you are a body builder and would put a strain on the body since it has to
find a way to supply the brain and body with necessary sugars. It would be expensive to follow. And here is an ingredient list from a low carb protein shake - perhaps you use a better one but none of them could be considered a whole food:
milk protein concentrate, calcium caseinate), sunflower oil, stabilsers (cellulose, sodium carboxymethyl cellulose, carrageenan, potassium phosphate), acidity regulator (potassium citrate), flavourings, sweeteners (sucralose, acesulfame-K), salt, colour (riboflavin).
 
Last edited:
still in maintenance week one

Sunday had 2200 calories, weighed in Monday at 176.
Monday had 2200 calories, weighed in Tuesday at 174. Anti-arthritis weights for exercise
Tuesday had 2000 calories, weighed in Wednesday at 174. Indoor biking and rowing for exercise.
Wednesday had 1900 calories, weighed in today at 176. Brill core exercises.

Oddly, I find I can still be hungry at these higher levels. However, my plan is to have 1600 calories today and tomorrow. Feeling light and trim with a springy feeling in my legs.
 
Aloe
Perhaps in the short worded context of forums such as this, you may have misunderstood what I was trying to say -or - read too much into it.
Sorry about that, no offense was meant by any means.

Let me write a longer explanation to try and clarify ....

I was only saying that if you find this current plan not working for you and you hit a plateu or wall where nothing seems to change, you may wish to re-evaluate the level of carbs in that diet plan being used.

It has been my experience that individuals with challenging metabolisms who try various diets with no success often need a diet similar to what I described or as Diane Kress explains in here New York Times best seller Metabolism Miracle.

Case in point, I just worked with 2 ladies in their 50s who weighted 180-190 lbs roughly
They said they had "tried everything" with no luck
Week after week, month after month they say they always bounced around the same 5 lb target.

Well they had not tried what Diane or myself was saying above.
Started working with them in July

They weight 135 and 141 today

Again... Whatever works for you is what is most important

But IF for some reason you don't find success with current approach, I was only saying for your particular genetics you may need to examine a "Metabolism B" solution and see if that helps better

Sorry for any misunderstanding again and hope that clarifies better
Thanks

P.S.
I would not recommend that protein supplement shake you listed ingredients for either.
A clean and pure high quality mixed whey is what I had in mind
 
Last edited:
Transition to maintenance completed.

I get what you are saying Mike - and after your success in the cases cited I can understand your missionary zeal. If I was interested in losing 30-40 pounds by totally changing my lifestyle I might give it a try.

However, what I am interested in is simply maintaining now at 174-176 for a week or two and then gently easing on down another 2 pounds and staying there.

Thursday had 1700 calories. Anti-arthritis weights for exercise. Friday weight was 174.
Friday had 2100 calories. Indoor bike and rowing for exercise. Today's weight was 175.

Plan for the week ahead - Keep it 2200 calories or less and keep exercising.
 
I intended to start another rotation in March - thought I did a posting but it's not here. Anyway, started passing a kidney stone the first day - Sunday March 3. Stone was large, backed up the urine and caused a kidney infection. Had the stone broken up by lithotripsy and though all the fragments are now gone, from the 3rd till now I haven't had much appetite, food is not all that appealing and I am 6 pounds lighter. Still don't have much energy and haven't done any exercise - hope to get back to it soon.
 
Came across this forum when doing research. I thought I'd join & add my experience...

So today is Day 5 of the Rotation Diet. I have ordered the revised version of the book and the recipe book companion.

I'm still excited about doing this because it seems to be working:

1) I am able to stick to the daily calories because I have something to look forward to. It's only three days of 600, and next 4 days of 900, then a whole week of 1200, then just one more tough week of 600/900 then.... I'm done.... until I choose to do it all again.

2) The results/rewards are almost instant gratification. I weigh myself everyday and see the number go down; not up! I can step on that scale with confidence and see my hard work pay off. Even on a day like today where it stayed the same, I am grateful it's not showing the same weight as last week.

3) The meals are healthy and physically satisfying. I can't remember the last time I had that much salad, vegetables and fruits! I actually feel proud of myself after I put the fork down - not ashamed, embarrased, guilty or angry. I enjoy most of the meals as I adjust my expectations of what delicious really does taste like. After reading Katahn's logical explanation of "superfoods", I can appreciate that most of my previous food choices were truly indulgences for my taste buds and the sugar and fat were highs, not natural flavors.

4) Not having to stress over what meals I have to make or eat is a relief. The daily menus are laid out in a clear and simple way. The ingredients and recipes are obtainable and the allowable substitutions are helpful.

5) I don't have to feel very hungry if I choose to eat my "safe fruit" or free vegetables. It's a little calming to know that I am depriving my body of calories, not food.

6) Last, but certainly important for me, is the support I receive from the book. Katahn explains this concept well, and let's his audience in on his well rounded approach to healthy weight loss. The book covers eating, excercising, maintaining the weight loss and discusses behaviorial modifications. I'm re-reading the last few chapters so I can prepare myself mentally for not being on the rotation diet in a couple of weeks.

Anyway, I list these benefits to reaffirm my decision to do this and stick to it, even though change is difficult for me. On a day where I got on the scaled and didn't see another dramatic weight loss of 2 lbs. since the day before, I have to remind myself that this decision to follow the plan is still very well worth it and I'm not going to let my impatience deter me from celebrating the 6 lbs. I've lost so far. I'm not going to downplay all the other benefits I've gained from eating healthier. By all accounts, this is nowhere near a typically "bad" day.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top