If its not shinsplints, what is it?

I've got a strange sharp pain on the inside of my lower calf, about a 3 inch line stretch running sort of along the soleus on the left leg.

It hurts to walk to the point where I limp. I always wear trainers for a sevear overpronation (have done for 2 years now) and when I have my trainers on walking is alot easier and sometimes pain free. Unfortunetly I can only afford one pair of trainers (and I'm sure I'd get spoken to if I began to wear my trainers everywhere!) so I keep my trainers for fitness/gym work alone. I wear basic flat shoes around otherwise and it hurts alot more just to walk around. If I try to run in my normal shoes -even 10 meters for a bus, I cannot do it, the pain is too much.

Running is something else- I hate not being able to run so get mad fits where I suddenly decide to run 11km an hour, the first 5 minutes are AGONY! and I don't always get much further then that. In the past I'd run an hour or so, now 5 minutes is too painful?! After about 5 minutes it normally feels a bit easier, after 15 I'm normally OK, but I get to about 40 minutes and the pain suddenly comes back MUCH worse then before and doesn't go for some days.

It feels like I have a large knot in my leg, right where the spot is. If I press it it does hurt alot but there is no swelling or brusing at all. Its almost as if someone has kicked me on my lower calf with steel tapped toe boots but theres just nothing to see!

I should add that I don't just jump into running, its normally mid way through a workout, say 30 minutes X-trainer, 20 minutes bike, 10 minutes tepper, 10 mins rowing (in any order) and running after that. But no matter how far into my workout I chose to run (if I do run) its always the same: first 5 minutes of agony, 10 minutes slightly easer. But anything over 15 minutes gives me pain the next day. I do warm up and cool down every time I work out and workout about 5 days a week 1-2 hrs a time. I know how to experience pain: I workout to a heart rate of av 75% according to my heart rate moniter and max out at 99% daily. I can do pain, but this shin thing is something else!

I have no idea what to do! I went to my GP who sent me for a scan: nothing showed up and so I was told I do not have shinsplints. I do not have a fracture and I should be fine. Only I'm not. I'm in agony when I walk in normal shoes or run full stop.

Ice, heat, muscle rub...tried them all. Its been about 6 months now and I don't know what to do! There is no swelling btw and I have had my gait checked many times. I have also been told by a few personal trainers that I have a good running technique. I have not had any falls or breaks in the past that would at all relate to this either.

Please help or suggest anything if you can!! :)
 
Last edited:
That sounds like shin splints, but there are other possibilities, including stress fractures, that obviously have to be diagnosed by a professional.

I was diagnosed with shin splints and was xrayed for stress fractures. My problems persisted for 6 months as I was training for a Half Ironman triathlon, but did not ease up until I stopped running altogether for 2 months and started using orthotics.
 
Thanks for your reply.

I did go for an x-ray, I thought shin splints would show up,(they may well have x-rayed for stress fractures too but thats not what concerned me at the time) I was told I do not have shin splints, that really suprized me and I don't know where I stand, what it is or why the *symptoms* match that of medial shin splints yet the doctor says I don't have them.

I guess I could go back, I mean, its been a year and a half and the problems still there- infact besides running, walking is the next most painful thing - its impossible to not walk, I cannot drive and I have to walk at least 10 minutes a day just to do day to day things. I normally end up walking much more then that.

Someone on another forum suggested trainers to wear day to day and I know from experience trainers do help (I wear them for a over-pronation) but I firstly cannot buy two pairs of trainers (being you need to not wear them all day every day and I'd still need a pair for the gym) I still find I get twinges though, even in trainers. (Just not as all-the-time as I do with normal trainers).

It has though now gone from just being the right leg to mainly being the left leg, the right leg seems to have gotten a lot better- but this could be as I have had to slow down more because of the new left leg pain and maybe the right leg has gotten a little better as a result of additional rest? (eg I cannot run at all now without chronic pain/limping as I run so I don't run at all. Its all bike and X-trainer)
 
I am totally confused. Stress fractures are detected by x-rays, but I cannot understand how a doctor could eliminate shin splints from x-rays. If I were you, I would see a different orthopedist.
 
I am totally confused. Stress fractures are detected by x-rays, but I cannot understand how a doctor could eliminate shin splints from x-rays. If I were you, I would see a different orthopedist.


Thats what the doctor said: an x-ray to see if I had shin splints- I went to see her saying thats what I thought I had, she said she wasn't sure and that I'd need an x-ray to confirm. Nothing showed up, pain still there and although I got referred to a physio he didn't blink when I said that the x-ray showed up no shin splints.

Am thinking I should go back to the doctor and re-ask, but don't have mushc faith in her- or any of the others in the surgeory either for that matter! Maybe its better to go back then do nothing. What have I got to lose, right?...
 
Back
Top