Weight-Loss Fat vs. calories

Weight-Loss
Well, still, it's not so much the actual amount of fat--say 20-30%--that I would be eating, but rather the transition from 10 grams of fat to higher number, that I'm worried about. Since my body is so used to such a small number, wouldn't it be excited to store all of the fat I'd suddenly be putting into my body?
 
Assuming you're in a caloric deficit.

No.
 
If you're looking for a transitional step, try adding more whole (unrefined) foods to your diet. If you seriously are getting under 10 grams of fat a day, I can't figure out how unless you eat mostly white rice / sugar / flour, maybe with some highly processed protein supplements. If you ate nothing but fresh pineapple, for instance, 1,500 calories a day would get you 13g of fat.

I'm with Steve that your body will not freak out at a sudden onslaught of fat. But if you wanted to give it a baby step, sub out whole grains / fruits and veggies / lean meats for whatever you're eating currently. Then start adding in things like nuts and avocados and oily fish.
 
This is one of the oddest threads I've read on the site. lol

Fat in one's diet definitely does not translate into body fat. Just because larger people often (not always) eat high fat diets, does not mean that if less fat is better, none is best. Our bodies need fats, and probably even some of the dreaded saturated fat given that its in such abundance in so many natural/unprocessed foods.

Try to avoid getting extremist about your diet. It just comes off as a bit odd to completely cut out an entire macronutrient like yummy fat.

BTW, this anti-fat thing started in the 80s and was discredited a long time ago.
 
Yup, then carbs took the limelight for being evil.

Don't you worry, there will always be something. It's how products are pushed easily.
 
Well, still, it's not so much the actual amount of fat--say 20-30%--that I would be eating, but rather the transition from 10 grams of fat to higher number, that I'm worried about. Since my body is so used to such a small number, wouldn't it be excited to store all of the fat I'd suddenly be putting into my body?

Just to sort of give you a real life experience about fat, et al. When I was in college and would come home for Christmas break.... for about the first week or two the only thing I would consume were McDonald's chocolate milkshakes... one or two a day... medium size. Clearly that is not healthy and by no means should I have ever done that... but I always ended up losing weight (which wasn't my intention... I just like sweets and was sick of regular food). Even though stuff like that is made up of mostly fats and carbs... it was still the basic principle that I consumed less calories than I needed and went into a deficit creating weightloss. That said, proper nutrition is best and having a balance in your diet is optimal, including fat. Plus the body needs an intake of fat to digest and absorb some essential nutrients found in fruits & veggies.

Vitamins A, D, E, and K are fat-soluble, meaning they can only be digested, absorbed, and transported in conjunction with fats. Fats are also sources of essential fatty acids, an important dietary requirement.

Fats play a vital role in maintaining healthy skin and hair, insulating body organs against shock, maintaining body temperature, and promoting healthy cell function. They also serve as energy stores for the body. Fats are broken down in the body to release glycerol and free fatty acids. The glycerol can be converted to glucose by the liver and thus used as a source of energy.

Fat also serves as a useful buffer towards a host of diseases. When a particular substance, whether chemical or biotic—reaches unsafe levels in the bloodstream, the body can effectively dilute—or at least maintain equilibrium of—the offending substances by storing it in new fat tissue. This helps to protect vital organs, until such time as the offending substances can be metabolized and/or removed from the body by such means as excretion, urination, accidental or intentional bloodletting, sebum excretion, and hair growth.

While it is nearly impossible to remove fat completely from the diet, it would be wrong to do so. Some fatty acids are essential nutrients, meaning that they can't be produced in the body from other compounds and need to be consumed in small amounts. All other fats required by the body are non-essential and can be produced in the body from other compounds.
Fat - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

I know that's a wikipedia entry, but there are other medical/clinical sources out there that back the information up.
 
If you're looking for a transitional step, try adding more whole (unrefined) foods to your diet. If you seriously are getting under 10 grams of fat a day, I can't figure out how unless you eat mostly white rice / sugar / flour, maybe with some highly processed protein supplements. If you ate nothing but fresh pineapple, for instance, 1,500 calories a day would get you 13g of fat.

I'm with Steve that your body will not freak out at a sudden onslaught of fat. But if you wanted to give it a baby step, sub out whole grains / fruits and veggies / lean meats for whatever you're eating currently. Then start adding in things like nuts and avocados and oily fish.

Well I only eat 1000-1100 calories a day, first of all.

All of the foods I eat are low fat, low calorie, etc.

35 calorie whole-wheat bread (with .5g fat per 2 slices); fat free yogurt, boneless, skinless chicken; fat free cheese; the rest are all vegetables and fruits. So I am eating the right things, I'm just not eating a lot of it.
 
35 calorie whole-wheat bread (with .5g fat per 2 slices); fat free yogurt, boneless, skinless chicken; fat free cheese; the rest are all vegetables and fruits. So I am eating the right things, I'm just not eating a lot of it.

I would disagree. Eating fat free everything is not eating the right things. And a good deal of "fat free" foods just have chemicals in place of the fat. They aren't good for your body. They are JUNK. Not everything of course, but many things.
 
I would disagree. Eating fat free everything is not eating the right things. And a good deal of "fat free" foods just have chemicals in place of the fat. They aren't good for your body. They are JUNK. Not everything of course, but many things.

What kind of things aren't "junk"?

The Healthy Life bread is a good source of fiber, and although I don't see any benefits in the fat free yogurt, it's got to be better than the calorie-packed sugar-filled ones with more than three times the calories as the kind I'm eating now.

It's not like I eat fat free cakes or candy or anything... I stay away from sweets completely.

But other than those three things (bread, yogurt, cheese) I just basically eat fruits, vegetables and lean meat like chicken and turkey with all the fat, juice, skin and bones taken out of it.
 
Well I only eat 1000-1100 calories a day, first of all.

All of the foods I eat are low fat, low calorie, etc.

35 calorie whole-wheat bread (with .5g fat per 2 slices); fat free yogurt, boneless, skinless chicken; fat free cheese; the rest are all vegetables and fruits. So I am eating the right things, I'm just not eating a lot of it.

Where are the following "super foods" in your diet:

olive oil
nuts
avocado

These foods have properties that are not found in other foods and are known to prevent a host of diseases. Your diet definitely is not complete without eating at least the olive oil on a regular basis. This is very main stream/common knowledge so its surprising that you wouldn't know that certain types of fats are absolutely necessary in one's diet.

What are your weight goals? In other words, why are you eating 1000 calories per day?
 
Where are the following "super foods" in your diet:

olive oil
nuts
avocado

These foods have properties that are not found in other foods and are known to prevent a host of diseases. Your diet definitely is not complete without eating at least the olive oil on a regular basis. This is very main stream/common knowledge so its surprising that you wouldn't know that certain types of fats are absolutely necessary in one's diet.

What are your weight goals? In other words, why are you eating 1000 calories per day?


I haven't eaten those because of the fat... like I said, I was under the impression that dietary fat = body fat, but I was wrong there apparently.

Right now I would maybe like to lose three or so pounds and maintain, but I have to be very careful because for a few months I went on a (more extreme) starvation diet, consisting of 600-700 calories per day. I lost more than 30 pounds, gained 10 or so back, and would like to keep myself from gaining any more back. Since my metabolism has slowed down significantly it'll be harder for me, which is why I'm trying to be very careful.
 
What kind of things aren't "junk"?

The Healthy Life bread is a good source of fiber, and although I don't see any benefits in the fat free yogurt, it's got to be better than the calorie-packed sugar-filled ones with more than three times the calories as the kind I'm eating now.
Just an FYI, found this out a moth or so ago. Yoplait Fat free yogurt has high fructose corn syrup as its second ingredient.
It is the tastiest yogurt out there and now I know why.
FF does not always mean the best for you. Look a Kraft Free dressings- same thing.
Flavor has to come from somewhere. I stick to mostly 'light' or 'diet' yogurt, cheese, dressings and mayo now.
 
there was an article I read recently -and I don't recall where i read it - in but i'll dig thru my folder... it stated that for yogurts, the low fat or full fat were better for your health and weight loss efforts than the fat free ones are...

I've seen so many people on this site and around the internet get hung up on fat free/sugar free/doesn't matter what it tastes like as long as it's free something... that they aren't looking at hte ingredients or the big picture..
 
Just an FYI, found this out a moth or so ago. Yoplait Fat free yogurt has high fructose corn syrup as its second ingredient.
It is the tastiest yogurt out there and now I know why.
FF does not always mean the best for you. Look a Kraft Free dressings- same thing.
Flavor has to come from somewhere. I stick to mostly 'light' or 'diet' yogurt, cheese, dressings and mayo now.

Well I don't eat Yoplait, I eat Danon Lite n' Fit. I'll have to check the ingredients, lol.

@maleficent: but if calories are what are significant in weight loss, how can the higher-calorie yogurts be better?
 
based on the ingredients in the product... in order to take out the fat - they're putting in other stuff that you probably don;t want in your body..
 
According to a 2006 obesity Review article (and I can't put my finger on the article -this was a blurb in a magazine article)

Conjuated Linoliec acid (CLA) found in low-fat yogurt has been thought to reduce body fat and improve body composition.

and that's why they suggest Low fat yogurt over fat free yogurt
 
Well I don't eat Yoplait, I eat Danon Lite n' Fit. I'll have to check the ingredients, lol.

@maleficent: but if calories are what are significant in weight loss, how can the higher-calorie yogurts be better?

I never buy anything without checking ingredients. That was just an example anyhow on how FF does not = good for you.

I tried lit & fit. Hated the taste and texture- not that my opinion really means anything in that regard.

And not to answer for maleficient but you do need to get over the calorie obsession. Calories in are important but you cannot discount the nutrients and general composition of regular or 'light' foods. Not eating a food purely because it is high in calories is not necessarily a good thing.

Some things high in calories are very good and essential for you.
It is about eating the right things.
 
Well, I'm counting my calories because if I go over my maintenence, I'll put on the weight really fast due to the fact that I had been eating so little. I gained almost 10 pounds in two weeks by eating 1700 calories a few months back, which was really scary.

But honestly besides from the yogurt, bread and cheese, everything else is fresh and unprocessed. One exception being 100 calorie popcorn, which I've only had twice in the past few months.
 
Back
Top