Argue whichever way you want, but in my opinion (valued at: $.02), lifting gloves are another step between lifting strength and applicable strength. Sure, the bar doesn't tear up the pads on your hand while you lift, and you can grip a little easier, and on your 110 pound frame it makes you look like a total judo badass... but I don't care if you can curl 500 pounds with one hand if you either don't have the grip strength to hold something up in real life, or tough enough hands to handle it.
Or maybe I've just broken and dislocated enough fingers to not care about what my hands look like.