Whey Protein - whats the real story

Ok what is the real scoop on Whey Protein. Right now I am using the generic brand from GNC, just 100% whey protein.

I always have two sides of the story about protein power.

1. One side says GNC Generic or other Generic brands suck and are a waste of money.

2. The other side says it doesnt matter about the whey protein and there all the same, so if GNC is cheaper which it usually is go for it.

What are your thoughts? I am really just looking for a sold whey protein, dont need one with Creatine, or Glutomine or whatever.

GNC ok, something else?

Thanks
 
Ive never used GNC's generic whey, was it Pro Performance btw?

Ive only used EAS and Optimum Nutrition. I tend to stay away from GNCs house brand, they're way overpriced.

Im with the thinking that whey is whey. The ON and EAS brands give you the most whey without all the extras that I have tried.
 
yeah, they GNC brand is cheapest in GNC, but if you get on the internet, or in other health stores you will find that it isn't near the cheapest..
 
don't know where you live but if you are anywhere in Canada the best prices I have found are at SupplementsCanada.com they have retail stores as well in some cities. Multiple brands so I would imagine you can find one you like.
 
Last edited:
#1. GNC is expensive. Take malkore's advice and shop online.

#2. You want to look, primarily, at the ratio of protein to serving size. For example:

A protein with a serving size of 24g with 22g of protein is really, really good (91% pure).

A protein with a serving size of 24g with 16g of protein (66% pure) is not so good -- and it's likely that your'e getting a lot of sugar, fat, and calories along with it. This isn't so bad if you're using it as a meal replacement, but if you're buying straight protein, go for purer.
 
Its been a while since i have had to deal with the buying and selling of supplements so some of this advice may be out of date, but find out what process the whey protien went through like what filtration method. Generally you wnt protien with teh highest bio availabilty like that derived from ion-exchange...but then agaiin this may not be the best method, but your health food store professional should have good advice. Personally I would rather pay abit more for a better product. Also as said already the amount of grams of protien per serving is important as well.

Stay away from combo stuff like creatine/glutamine/ protien combos...they are just gimmicks, from what I can recall taking these supplements seperately and at slightly differnent times improves absorption (though i could be wrong about that too)
 
chris said:
Stay away from combo stuff like creatine/glutamine/ protien combos...they are just gimmicks, from what I can recall taking these supplements seperately and at slightly differnent times improves absorption (though i could be wrong about that too)

No, you're right, but the more important aspect to consider is the amount of these things you're getting. We had a customer in last Thursday who wanted a "super protein" -- one that had a high amount of protein, glutamine, amino acids, and EFA's. Well, we had one that had most of what he wanted, but if you looked at the servings, you ended up with something like 250mg of Glutamine, for example.

For those of you who aren't glutamine addicts like me, you should get a minimum of 5g (5,000 mg compared to the 250 mg in the combo protein) in a day, though usually I recommend 10g a day - 5g after your workout, and 5g before bed.

So the amount you're getting is negligible. If what you're basically looking for is a way to reduce the amount of supplements you have to take for your training regimen, you can stick to the major groups : a protein, an amino supplement, creatine, a combo EFA supplement (they're usually sold this way anyway). I also recommend on top of your amino supplement taking glutamine separately -- but if you don't mind the downtime after your workouts, that's between you and your muscles :)

Regarding absorption, you don't want to overload your system with nutrients all at once because many of them will get wasted. Your body has a limited capacity to utilize what it ingests, and trying to get all your supplementation out of the way at once is usually a way to not get results from them. That's why 6-a-days tend to be more effectual than one-a-days: the absorption throughout the day means that you're constantly utilizing the nutrient, rather than an hour-long utilization followed by a period of nothing.

This is why tablets are better than caplets for potent multivitamins - you want that array of vitamins to be absorbed slowly. This is the same principle behind taking your supplements with food - you slow down absorption, which leads to greater utilization/bio-availability.
 
Back
Top