Weight-Loss What am I doing wrong?

Weight-Loss

moulinroux

New member
I've been working a self-designed program for the past month or so and haven't lost a pound. I'm 5'7" and currently weigh 184 lbs.

I work out every morning before eating breakfast. 45 minutes of cardio, usually on the crosstrainer or treadmill. Then I usually eat either a bowl of oatmeal or a whole wheat english muffin with hummus.

I have a 300-400 calorie lunch, usually soup with an apple and a granola bar.

Then a 500-700 calorie dinner, like whole wheat pasta with some sauce or some egg whites with toast and fruit.

Overall I've been eating 1,200-1,500 calories per day and doing my workout every morning (usually an hour on Sat & Sun too) but I haven't lost a single pound in 4 weeks. I feel better and can run longer/harder, but I'm not losing any weight (which is my goal).

What am I doing wrong? Any advice? Please help! And Happy New Year!
 
The food choices you make all seem to be wheat based. What about increasing fruit and vegetable intake?

How about a smoothie for breakfast: nut or seed milk with banana, raw nuts (soaked overnight) and hemp powder (protein packed). Throw in some dates or apricots for added sweetness.

Do you eat fish or chicken? How about grilled fish or white meat with a large green salad for lunch. If vegetarian or vegan, a large green salad with other vegetables you like and a nice avocado based dressing? (Make the dressing yourself or for a real quick dressing – flax seed oil and a few drops of tamari. This is the dressing I use all the time for my salads.). For dinner, 4 oatcakes with hummus or a homemade mushroom pate with a large mixed salad (ensure you make this interesting and varied) or a huge bowl of soup. The only grain product here is the oats.

Consider setting aside a budget for a personal trainer (say for one month) 3 times a week. Sometimes the regime we set ourselves may not be sufficient.

Forget about counting calories and focus on getting healthy instead. Make small but simple changes such as those I’ve mentioned.

Lastly, you have only been at it for one month so give it a chance. Also, throw the scales away and be guided by your changing body shape.
 
Don't get discouraged. In this case, it probably IS a case where you are gaining (heavy) muscle versus fat.

Do you feel different? Do your clothes fit better?

Keep your chin up.

jmace
 
Your weight is only one measure of your overall fitness. Have you tried comparison measurements of your waist, arms, chest, etc. You might weigh the same but I'll bet you have moved some of that weight around. Muscle mass is heavier than fat and also burns more calories. Muscle mass is like Novocain, it takes a while to work but when it does it's great.

With your diet, remember the numbers 3 and 5. Three basic principles, variety, moderation, and balance. Five food groups in the food pyramid, grain, fruits, vegetables, meat and dairy, and fats, oils, and sweets. Balance your diet using moderation with the variety of foods available from the pyramid.
 
I've been working a self-designed program for the past month or so and haven't lost a pound. I'm 5'7" and currently weigh 184 lbs.

What is this self-designed program? Its specific content, times per week, how long, etc.

Then I usually eat either a bowl of oatmeal or a whole wheat english muffin with hummus. I have a 300-400 calorie lunch, usually soup with an apple and a granola bar. Then a 500-700 calorie dinner, like whole wheat pasta with some sauce or some egg whites with toast and fruit.

The diet (at least) in what you posted, is primarily Carbohydrate based, and displays very little protein. Its my opinion, in the face of a calorie deficit (especially), proteins in the diet become paramount (not to undermine its overall importance in the diet in general). Therefore, I would suggest to increase your proteins in your diet. There is very little information reference "good" fat intake. And, if this is low, I would also suggest increasing this (if applicable).

Overall I've been eating 1,200-1,500 calories per day and doing my workout every morning (usually an hour on Sat & Sun too) but I haven't lost a single pound in 4 weeks. I feel better and can run longer/harder, but I'm not losing any weight (which is my goal).

This is what we know thus far (as much as your post allows):

1. Your diet is high in Carbohydrates.

2. Your diet is low in Protein.

3. Very little fat consumption information.

4. You are eating between 1200 to 1500 calories per day.

5. You do not display your approximated MT-Line of calories.

What we do not know:

1. Prior to developing your self-made fitness program, your activity level prior to commencement.

2. Your dietary habits prior to your new diet and fitness program.

3. Any health related complications.

4. Unknown if you are taking any supplements (such as Creatine Mono, which can effect water levels).


The weight scale can be a deceptive device--especially to one just beginning a training/dieting program.

Let me give you a rather brief example:

If you ate normally (so-to-speak) prior to your new self-designed program, and were basically inactive (for lack of argument), and then "suddenly" introduce some "brand new" stimulus to the body (such as your low-calorie consumption and fitness training), the body "can", "can" react rather strong (keeping things equal).

But, it can be a two-prong bodily reaction. First, the "probability" and "odds" of strength/muscle increase are rather high. Second, there is a comparable likelihood of strong fat reduction reaction.

Sometimes..........the disparity between the two is what causes some people problems..........when looking at the scale, rather than looking at their self in the mirror with educated eyes (like taking a picture when starting, and taking a picture at the end of the month).

For example, if the rate of strength/muscle increase and fat loss (are the same) hypothetically, the scale isn't going to reflect much weight change, when........in fact there has been.

There "can be" weight gain, for example, if the strength/muscle gain rate "exceeds" the rate of fat loss, the net result can be weight gain (which is a good thing).

In addition, it is quite "normal" for the body to gain/lose several pounds (dependent) of "weight" during the course of a day (added feces in the colon, depleted feces in the colon [taking a dump], as examples).

Another potential possibility is that since (at least on appearance) you Carbohydrates are high, you could be carrying some excess water, which adds another variable possibility in your weight (displacement) equation.

I am not saying this is happening to you, but this is something to think about.

How have you calculated your calories. What "approximator" did you use?

When considering your MT-Line each day. What kind of calorie deficit does 1200 to 1500 calories bring you?

Have you seen any changes in your physical appearance?

Do not be discouraged yet.


Best wishes for your continued success,


Chillen
 
i wouuld try to cut out the pasta and replace with something like tuna or turkey or grilled chicken...also, maybe you are lifting too heavy and should be doing light weights cuz muscle does weigh more than fat
 
i wouuld try to cut out the pasta and replace with something like tuna or turkey or grilled chicken

Why?


...also, maybe you are lifting too heavy and should be doing light weights cuz muscle does weigh more than fat

If you're dieting, that's pretty much the exact opposite you want to do in many cases.
 
i wouuld try to cut out the pasta and replace with something like tuna or turkey or grilled chicken...also, maybe you are lifting too heavy and should be doing light weights cuz muscle does weigh more than fat

Yeah, that's pretty bad advice there...sorry. I would, however, replace white-flour based carbs with whole grains. If the ingredients don't say whole grain, it's white-flour based, even if it says, "wheat" on it. Try less bread and more brown rice, too. It's not too expensive and very filling. Also, try adding a bit more protein in there as well. It'll help! Also, I do not agree with the advice about lifting lighter. There is such a myth that women shouldn't lift heavy, and it's so WRONG. The stronger and more muscular you get, the easier it will be to burn fat and keep it off. The number on the scale is just a part of the equation, don't let it discourage you. Also, be patient. It took a lot of time to put the weight on, so it's not going to come off overnight. Try for awhile instead of relying solely on the scale for tracking progress, taking some photos and measurements of your body instead. Sometimes you lose inches before pounds! Keep up the good work, tweak your exercise and diet routine to work for you, and you'll see results! :)
 
Nutrient density and fiber. White rice has had all the nutrients stripped then replaced with enrichment. But even with the nutrients put back in, the fiber is gone. Fiber is more filling and takes your body longer to process, so it sticks with you longer. And the original nutrients are still in it, unlike white rice.

Nutrient density is the reason I recommend whole grains. I personally feel more satiated and better when I eat whole grains.
 
Thanks for the clarification.

I eat a mixture of whole wheat and white wheat carbohydrates... I account for calories, I account for macros including fiber, and it doesn't make a difference in terms of my fat loss/ body comp or my health readings.

Nor has it my clients.

Less rigidity the better imo.

That's my take.
 
Back
Top