Unable to maintain heart rate over 135 for long

I hear about all these other folks hitting heart rates of 160, 170, etc. but I cannot maintain a heart rate over 135 without gasping for air. I am 47, 6'0", 205, and have been training consistently for 6 months. I had a heart catherization and stent done in November, but my cardiologist gave me the green light to do whatever I wanted.

It seems to me that my cardiovascular system is working okay in that it doesn't have to beat too fast but the breathing is the limiting factor. Does this make sense?
 
I hear about all these other folks hitting heart rates of 160, 170, etc. but I cannot maintain a heart rate over 135 without gasping for air. I am 47, 6'0", 205, and have been training consistently for 6 months. I had a heart catherization and stent done in November, but my cardiologist gave me the green light to do whatever I wanted.

It seems to me that my cardiovascular system is working okay in that it doesn't have to beat too fast but the breathing is the limiting factor. Does this make sense?

Don't forget, those training heart rates are general guidleines for the entire population ( often ) based on a calculation ( 220 - your age = Max Heart Rate ). The calcuation may only apply with some degree of accuracy to 70% +-/ of the population. Don't feel you have to be confined to some objective pre-determined training heart rate based on this sort of calc. For example, if your calc for aerobic training of 70%+/- MHR ( i.e 120 bpm ) feels too strenuous and has you gasing for air, the calc may have over-stated your training heart to train aerobically. Remember, if you are gapsing for air, you aren't training aerobically - aerobics implies ' with oxygen ' after all.

Instead, I'd opt for a more ' subjective ' measure. One of the more common ones used is the " Talk Test " - it's focus is on breathing during exercise. Here is a basic description......


Talk Test

The final method for measuring exercise intensity is the Talk Test. Like the RPE, the talk test is subjective and should be used in conjunction with taking a pulse. The talk test is quite useful in determining your comfort zone of aerobic intensity, especially if you are just beginning an exercise program.

Using this method, the goal is to work at a level where you can answer a question, but not comfortably carry on a conversation. In simple terms, you would be working out too hard if you have to take a breath between every word you say. Conversely, you would be exercising too easily if you could sing several phrases of a song without breathing hard.

Work at an intensity that allows you to breathe comfortably and rhythmically throughout all phases of your workout. This will ensure a safe and comfortable level of exercise. If you are breathless, or can't talk, you're working too hard! Lower the resistance level and slow down. If you experience dizziness or lightheadedness, you may be overexerting yourself and should stop.

The Talk Test has been confirmed as a simple and accurate method of gauging intensity that doesn’t require any equipment or learning. Try your own Talk Test during your next workout (and compare it to your normal heart rate count if you’re skeptical). You may be able to replace your heart rate monitoring with this simple test during all of your workouts, or at least when counting your pulse is inconvenient.

 
Last edited:
I had a heart catherization and stent done in November, but my cardiologist gave me the green light to do whatever I wanted.

Are you taking any type of heart medication? Beta blockers for instance will keep the heart rate artificially low. Other meds can have a similar effect.
 
Ha, I actually have been doing about this in GSCE PE for the past few weeks. You have to take into account that your age will affect on your Maximum target heart rate. Pushing yourself beyond that level could result in a heart attack. You have to go at a pace that you feel comfortable with. As it's been said before, you have to get into a rhythm when you're breathing, that is comfortable with you.
 
All great responses!!!

Wrangell: Yes, I fail the talk test at 135 bpm. The talk test will allow me to go about 70% of my theoretical max heart rate, 125. That will be my new goal.

Georgen1: Yes, I am taking beta blockers and Ace Inhibitors and, while I am not certain of their effects, now I recall my cardiologist saying that they do suppress my blood pressure (that is why I don't bother checking my bp anymore). Excellent observation! When I graduate from them later this year I will post followup results. Thanks for reminding me of this factor, which explains a lot and may be the best explanation.

Mysterious: I am under a cardiologist's care and he has given me the green light to go 85% of my theoretical max heart rate (147 in my case) which I stay way below. Thanks.
 
have you tried interval training,you get your HR higher for shorter periods that way your heart gets used to it,but check with your doc first.
 
Beta Blockers

if i was you i would try and get your doctor to take you off beta blockers as they make exercise very hard going i was on beta blockers for a while a few years ago and exercise felt i was running with lead in my shoes not to mention my heart rate wouldnt go very high I told my doctor and he switched me to ace inhibitors which lowers blood pressure like beta blockers and has no effect on supressing heart rate you dont need both beta and ace , incidently i no longer take ace as i take natural alternative medicine to keep it undercontrol a lot more expensive but iam able to exercise properly
 
if i was you i would try and get your doctor to take you off beta blockers as they make exercise very hard going i was on beta blockers for a while a few years ago and exercise felt i was running with lead in my shoes not to mention my heart rate wouldnt go very high I told my doctor and he switched me to ace inhibitors which lowers blood pressure like beta blockers and has no effect on supressing heart rate you dont need both beta and ace , incidently i no longer take ace as i take natural alternative medicine to keep it undercontrol a lot more expensive but iam able to exercise properly

Jasper, this is a fairly old thread, but it reminds me to give up an update. Thanks. During my last checkup in August, I requested that I be taken off beta blockers (I was on both bb and ace-inhibitors) as Georgen pointed out, they suppress heart rate and therefore performance. He reluctantly agreed, with one condition; that I wear a heart rate monitor. I wore (and still do) the hrm for about a month and without the bb, my heart rate stays at about 135 - 145 for extended periods up to 3 or 4 hours with peaks up to 165, which is what I would consider normal at least for me.

I don't really know why I am taking the Ace-inhibitors now as I do not have high bp (morning bp is 110/70) but I am not suffereing from any side effects so I will continue with the ace inhibitors.
 
Back
Top