Myths/Questions

kakutzi

New member
Just had a few things i wanted clarification on....

1) Is it true that when excercising (cardio) that your body doesnt start burning fat till you have been doing it for at least 30min?

2) Is it true that Citrus fruits are the only food that can be eaten late at night and that will keep your metabolism going throughout the night?

3) Does liquid meals (such as a protein shake) raise your metabolism just as much as the same quantity of solid food?

Any answers will be appreciated....
 
1) Is it true that when excercising (cardio) that your body doesnt start burning fat till you have been doing it for at least 30min?
This is a really complex issue that people try to "boil down" to some kind of rule ... and it just doesn't work that way. The bottom line is NO .. this is not true. Any exercise you do burns calories, and ultimately burning more calories than you consume will burn fat. That's the bottom line.

That doesn't mean that during various stages of our exercise, and depending on the intensity, our bodies don't switch back and forth between the kinds of reserves they burn immediately. This article has a good explanation of the process at a very basic level:
When your body moves (or any cell in your body does any type of ”work”) it needs energy. The amount of energy needed is measured as a unit of heat—or a calorie. The fuel to produce this energy comes from several sources, mostly fat and carbs (glucose), and occasionally amino acids (protein). How and when fat is ‘”burned” (or metabolized to provide energy for the body) and how that affects body fat levels and weight is a very complex area of physiology research. There have been hundreds, maybe thousands, of studies exploring the utilization of fat for energy under a variety of different conditions. There is still much to be understood, but this is how we know it works so far:

Whether you are watching TV or running around a track, the fuel your body uses to give you the calories your cells need for energy comes from burning mostly fat and carbs. Your body nearly always burns a mix of both fat calories and carb calories. So normally, for every calorie burned, the fuels are around a 50/50 split of both fat and carbs.

How hard you are moving during exercise is one major determinant of which fuel your body will use. Carbs provide a faster energy source. So whenever you need to do something fast or produce force, carbs are the better fuel. Fats are favored during long, low-intensity activities. It’s not that you stop using one or the other fuel, it’s that the ratio of both shifts depending on your activity. In more scientific terms, you alternate between aerobic (more fat-burning) and anaerobic (more carb-burning) metabolism.

2) Is it true that Citrus fruits are the only food that can be eaten late at night and that will keep your metabolism going throughout the night?
Utter and complete hogwash. :)

You should eat balanced meals with a range of nutrients (including veggies, fruits, lean protein, and complex carbs) and within a reasonable calorie range (not too many, not too few). There's no such thing as "the only food that will keep your metabolism going" because factually, if you're metabolism isn't "going" then you're dead ... and what you eat won't matter. :D If you are providing proper nutrition to your body throughout the day, then your metabolism will go just fine.

3) Does liquid meals (such as a protein shake) raise your metabolism just as much as the same quantity of solid food?
I'm not really sure what you mean by solid food "raising your metabolism"? Are you talking about the thermogenic effect of digestion (in other words, that eating and digestion causes your body temperature to rise, and therefore burn more calories)? If that's what you're talking about, then the truth is that eating is not going to "raise your metabolism" enough to make that much difference in your weight loss. Again, going back to what I said above about the citrus fruit, eating proper foods in reasonable quantities and making sure you get a nice balance of vitamins and minerals will sustain your metabolism and make it possible for you to exercise. If you get that through whole foods or a combination of whole foods and protein shakes, either way is fine.

I don't really recommend using protein shakes as food or meal substitutes for a lot of reasons, which I'll be happy to go into if you'd like me to. But as a supplement or an occasional meal replacement, there's no reason why protein drinks or protein powder aren't fine.

Hope that helps answer your questions some.
 
1) I completely agree with kara on point 1, and that article is a really good way to explain it without goinginto too much physiology. There is no magic number for when your body switches from carbs to fat, or vice versa. And if your trying to lose weight, thats not really the question you want to be spending your time on anyways because frankly it doesnt matter whether your body is burning fats or carbs to get the job done. What should matter to you is how efficient and balanced your workouts are, healthy nutrition to contribute to body fat % decreasing and the building of lean muscle which will contribute to a higher metabolism and a more efficient body when your not exercising.

2) Ive never heard of that citrus fruits theory before, but it sounds pretty ridiculous. Stick to a healthy balanced diet, lots of fruits and vegetables, lean protiens, meals spread out throughout the day, limited or none processed foods, and you'll be good to go.

3) As far as protien supplements go, there is nothing wrong with them, but most people don't need them. The average person gets more then enough protien in their diet from whole foods anywyas and any excess protien is just excreted in urine. However, using these types of supplements for pre/post workout shakes can be beneficial as that is the time when your body needs the nutrients the most and most people don't have time to cook a chicken breast at the gym ;).

Hope that helps

Cameron Makarchuk
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thanks Kara and cmak for your responses...

Kara... in regards to asking if shakes will increase your metabolism as much as solid food.. How i was meaning it was i thought that meals kick started your metabolism again, as opposed to it being lowered when you havent eaten for a long period and your body goes into starvation mode. But you have clarified that for me so thanks :)
 
Kara... in regards to asking if shakes will increase your metabolism as much as solid food.. How i was meaning it was i thought that meals kick started your metabolism again, as opposed to it being lowered when you havent eaten for a long period and your body goes into starvation mode.
Noooooo. :)

"Starvation mode" doesn't work that way. You don't go into starvation mode by missing a meal or fasting for 8 hours while you sleep or whatever. Starvation mode (as most dieters think of it) is more about how your body reacts to a long term calorie/nutritional deprivation. Long term being the key there ... when you eat too little for too long, then your body begins to conserve nutrients and fat. But that doesn't happen overnight or with one meal.
 
Back
Top