Forget Science

A while ago, T-nation ran an article asking various trainers what was one think that they believed to be true that cannot currently be backed by science. So I ask you the same question: What do you believe about training or nutrition that you have no scientific reasoning for?

Personally I believe that calories coming from liquid and calories coming from food have a much different effect on the body. I think that if you consumed all your macro's in liquid form, and went over your daily maintenance level, you would gain less fat than if you consumed the exact same thing but in solid food form. I have no evidence for this, it is just what I believe.
 
Here's some key elements I believe (no way of backing it with science):

* Maintaining healthy weight occurs when you don't think about it.

* It's 99.9% mental, no matter how heavy or far.

* Lining up the bars so that it's parallel with the crack/dent on the ceiling/floor will increase your strength by folds.

* Washing your pants once a week increases running distance.

* Using the far right lane will cause you to swim longer.

* Passing by a member of the opposite sex will cause you to trip.

* Pain makes you go further and farther than you ever imagined possible.
 
Last edited:
Knocking off dallens because all of em are false ;)

amp, science could easily find that out. My suspision though would be that the liquid form would cause the slightest more weight gain, because theres less work for the body to digest.
 
Knocking off dallens because all of em are false ;)

amp, science could easily find that out. My suspision though would be that the liquid form would cause the slightest more weight gain, because theres less work for the body to digest.

Or maybe the liquid form would cause slight weight loss cause the calories wouldn't get absorbed as thoroughly cause it passes through your body faster.
 
Flyes are a better exercise for increasing chest size than barbell bench presses.

The biggest benefit of drinking a lot of water throughout the day is that you can throw your alarm clock away, because you'll be gettin' up early enough thanks to all that H2O.

Consumption of alcohol is by far the quickest way for a man to grow back his 'spare tire'.
 
This is a good thread.

What do you believe about training or nutrition that you have no scientific reasoning for?

"Overtraining" is a fancy way to say "not in good enough shape" :D

Back should be trained every workout.

Faster is better in all aspects of lifting.

Technique of exercises changes based upon the sport or goal being trained for.
 
Some of this to could be proven, I dunno, I'm just saying what I believe and common sense tells me without having to try to find some studies that back it up.

If you want to be good at deccelleration you don't have to do eccentric movements slowly, that will make you able to deccellerate slowly, you want to be able to do it quickly, thus, doing the eccentric fast and being able to stop the movement just in time and convert it into a concentric movement is the way to go as this will teach you to deccellerate a movement fast, something you need in sports.

There is more experience in training than there is modern science. People have been weight training longer than modern science have been around thus we must not forget the importance of what years of experience has told us works. If a scientific study says to do one thing, but your experience tells you that another way is more efficient, then follow your experience. modern science is an excellent tool, but it must be used together with experience.
I say "modern science" because otherwise someone would come and argue that looking at what people have done before or looking at what you have done before and drawing conclusions is what science is, this is not what I mean, I mean scientific studies and all that crap :p

Agree with the over training part, G! Though I think it is possible you train yourself into the ground, it will depend on your fitness level and over training is hard, you would probably have to train harder than you would be mentally able to. I've been hitting the gym for 2 hours 3 times a week these last few weeks. all moves are compounds. here is an example day (I don't take the percentages too seriously, if it is 3 reps, I do what I can for 3 reps, etc)
Day 3
Snatch From Knee 80% 3r, 85% 2r, 80% 2r x 2s
Clean & Jerk 80%[2+1], 85%[1+2], 85%[2+1], 80%[1+2]
Snatch Pull 80% 3r, 90% 2r, 85% 2r, 80% 3r x 2s, 80% 2r x 2s
Front Squat 80% 3r, 90% 2r, 85% 2r, 90% 2r, 85% 2r, 80% 3r x 2s
Good Morning 80% 3r, 85% 2r x 3s, 80% 2r x 2s
Bent over row
Bench press
abs

A lot of big compounds.
also, every time I have been designing my own routine, everyone has told me that it has too much and I will crash and burn. that is yet to happen

At a higher bodyfat percentage your body will gain muscle more easily. the reason being that the body is relaxing in terms of fat gain. as we know, the body wants to add fat to be able to survive if harsh times comes a long. when you have a higher BF% your body doesn't have to worry too much about that and can thus focus more on adding muscle.
 
Rotating your shoulders backwards twice before any chest pressing movement makes you lift more :D

Shaking your legs out before squating aslo helps
 
Although it's slightly backed by some science, I would say that our race/ethnicity/genetics play an even bigger role in how we respond to different types of foods than we think. There is some research on it, but I don't think it's widely accepted yet. Diet "experts" are still prescribing a "one size fits all" diet. For example, some say that everyone should avoid white starches. But what about certain cultures where they subsist off of potatoes? What if those were your ancestors? I think there's some evidence to support that their bodies process those starches differently than other people. Maybe they have lower rates of type 2 diabetes because they can handle more refined/white starches.
 
* Lining up the bars so that it's parallel with the crack/dent on the ceiling/floor will increase your strength by folds.

I completely believe this. Although, it's probably just my OCD acting up. I have actually ended a set early, adjusted the bench, then went back to lifting because I couldn't stand the bar being uneven. I'm not usually that nuts, its just that it zaps my concentration.
 
I use the lines on the ceiling to find my movement groove with the bar, & it helps me stay focused in that zone. Of course it helps you lift more. Hehe!
 
haha. awsome thread man.

mmm.

Your mental attitude can effect any outcome even if not 'scientifically correct.'
 
Choc milk is the ultimate PWO.

does it have to be chocolate milk? ehhhh, i'm serious.
 
Back
Top