I dunno ... would you rather be fat or have stretch marks?
huh? you guys must have it easy because I never had the option of an either or.
I have stretch marks literally everywhere. Fortunately now, most of them are faded. When I was in high school, it was really bad. I had them on my gut, my man boobs, underneath my armpit the whole way down the side of my body to my sides and around to my back. My arms... oh my... I got them on my biceps from my armpit to my elbow, and some on the inside of my forarm near my elbow. I never wore sleevless shirts even for summer workouts, and always tried to hide my arms. There was this girl I had a huge crush on in high school that I stood next to in choir, and I was always more comfortable in winter when I could wear long sleeved shirts and sweaters. Whenever I was wearing short sleeved, I would get so anxious hoping she wouldn't see the stretch marks on my arms. I even have stretch marks on my knees.
The worst part about it is my complexion in pretty pasty - I can get some tan, but I'm mostly pretty white. In HS, ALL those stretch marks I just mentioned were bright pink and red! It was horrible... you think having to take off your shirt in front of people is bad enough when you're just fat - try doing it when you look like a pink and pale zebra! At least though, I was sorta one of the cool kids in HS. Not really in the "most popular clique", but I pretty much got along with everybody equally, so I didn't really get ridiculed too much for it, and when people did see me with my shirt off, most just asked what they were, if they hurt, and what causes them.
Nowadays, things aren't so bad. Over time, and with some weight loss, ALL of my marks have faded to my skin color. I don't yet have that wrinkly stretched skin look yet because I still have a bunch of fat I have to lose, but my stretch marks right now are so much better than they used to be that its a non issue. You can't even really tell they're there if you're looking at me from a distance, and if my wife notices them, she's never made any comments that gave away that she cares, even when I was gaining weight a couple years ago and they started turning pink again.
So basically, the choice for me was fat with bright pink highly noticeable stretch marks, or slimmer with faded, possibly wrinkly stretch marks... I think its pretty much a no brainer, and no cause for discouragement for me.