Sport Cereal For Dinner: Is That "Normal"

Sport Fitness
What’s for dinner tonight? I bet it’s not Raisin Bran or Grape Nuts, but why not? Research shows that whole-grain cereal is an excellent source of vitamins and fiber, and is low in calories and saturated fat. But in America, cereal is supposed to be eaten for breakfast. It’s not supposed to be eaten for dinner. We can’t do that. Says who? The advertisers, that’s who. What if Kelloggs launched a “dinner cereal?” and put a lot of marketing dollars behind the idea? Certainly this “dinner cereal” wouldn’t be different from any other cereal; it would just give us “permission” to steer away from the norm and do things a little differently. And I guarantee there’d be a lot less overweight people in the world.

About 7 years ago I put my theory to the test. I ate cereal for dinner 5 nights a week for about 4 months, and I can honestly say that my stomach was flatter than ever, I never felt full or bloated and I got used to it pretty quickly. In fact, I found myself driving home from work excited about what cereal I was going to have that night, and I looked forward to it. I felt great.

Our overweight problem is largely cultural. Big, dinnertime meals are part of what we do even though research shows that consuming our largest meal at night is a big reason for our bulging waist-lines. Not long ago I read an interesting study about the timing of our eating. The researchers compared the eating habits of some community in Scotland and compared them to ours. This community was in a farming region and the people, on average, consumed the same amount of calories per day that we do, but they did not have a weight problem. The reason: Breakfast was their big meal. About two thirds of their daily calories were consumed in the morning and they ate sensible lunches and dinners. In our culture, we consume two thirds of our calories after 5:00 P.M. The body’s metabolism slows down significantly after 6:00 P.M. and our bodies just aren’t burning all of those calories effectively.

Timing is everything. Makes sense, doesn’t it?

In our world, we do what seems normal, what everyone else is doing. A family sitting around the dinner table eating a bowl of Cheerios with sliced bananas sounds ludicrous. It just doesn’t fit into our cultural schema. But obviously something has got to change in our country or we’re just going to keep eating ourselves to death. Try the cereal plan for a few weeks and see if you lose weight. There is such a huge selection of good, healthy cereals out there so you don’t have to worry about getting board. Dare to be different.
 
The timing on meals has been blamed for obesity and various other things. As long as the gap between meals is not massive, single meal a day style, this has been proven as the least important factor in diet since it was shouted from the rooftops. Of course there were studies showing a group of people eating late at night gained weight faster than those not doing so but the study was later revealed to be a farce because they were being given this on top of the control groups intake so basically proving eating more meant putting on more weight.
I am basing this on data from around 5 years ago but up to that point every other study to find out the effect of timing on diet were 3 or more well spaced meals were given showed no conclusions that weren't within the margin for error. There may be new data but in all seriousness what you eat has far more bearing than when you eat it.
There is of course nothing wrong with cereal any time of day and traditions regarding food are crazy. So by all means eat bran and bananas for family dinner and enjoy it. Just don't expect to lose several pounds by eating the same food at different times, reductions in intake and increase in activity is still the key and both need to be done sensibly.
Feeling bloated etc. comes from overeating and vegetating and the evening slow down is not automatic it is lifestyle based. If you eat a massive meal and recline back in front of the TV, something we all enjoy after a long day, the body will take the opportunity to relax too and slow the metabolism. If you eat, let it settle and then train, your body won't do this because it knows the energy is needed.

Classic case here of take nobody's word for it. Studies all have outlyers, individuals that were way outside the main groups in various directions. For clarity these are normally ignored as there is a strong chance of outside influence on their results, not sticking to program is most common but other factors are totally genuine. This means that all the evidence in the world doesn't mean you are guaranteed to get or fail to get results, because you could be an outlyer, it does however mean your chances are not good of getting results the research didn't show.
The concepts can also be similar to faith healing or placebos, both of which have a long history of success. If you believe in something there is a good chance you will do better than someone who doesn't. I do better than many who look identical because I arrogantly assume I can, the trade off is I am sometimes wrong hence training to failure.
 
Back
Top